Arizona Daily Sun (Original) Posted on April 8, 2020 by Susan Montoya Bryan for the Associated Press
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. — The killing of four Mexican gray wolves by U.S. wildlife officials has drawn the ire of environmentalists who say management of the species is undercutting efforts to restore the endangered predators to the American Southwest.
Documents made public Tuesday show the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service took the action in March after hazing, diversionary food caches and other non-lethal means failed to get the predators to stop killing cattle in two rural areas of western New Mexico.
The latest deaths highlight a conflict that has persisted since reintroduction began more than 20 years ago. Over the last year, ranchers have seen a record number of cattle kills as the wolf population has increased.
Regional officials issued the removal order last month as a last resort, agency spokeswoman Aislinn Maestas said.
“The purpose of a removal is to influence and/or change wolf pack behavior to reduce the potential for recurrent wolf depredations on livestock, while continuing to promote wolf recovery,” she said in an email.
One wolf was killed by federal workers on March 23. Three others were taken out a few days later.
It’s still too soon for the wolf recovery team to determine the effect on pack dynamics or prey habits.
Michael Robinson of the Center for Biological Diversity is a long-time critic of how the recovery effort has been managed. He said last month's actions amounted to the largest lethal removal in the Southwest since 2009, when nine members of an Arizona pack were killed.
“This killing spree shows us how little has changed in the mindset of wolf managers since the days of federal wolf extermination a century ago,” he said. “The Fish and Wildlife Service would rather shoot wolves than require ranchers to protect their animals on public lands."
Two wolves from the Mangas pack, which roams near Arizona-New Mexico state line, and two members of the Prieto pack further to the southeast were targeted as part of the removal orders. Both packs are in known problem areas where wolf-livestock conflicts have been regularly documented.
The Prieto pack began preying on livestock after several members of the pack had been injured by non-government traps, environmentalists said.
Environmental groups contend that ranchers aren't doing enough to protect their herds. They point to instances in which cow carcasses have been left on the range, drawing wolves in.
Ranchers argue they have tried to haze the wolves or have hired range riders to scare off the animals to no avail. They describe the wolves as brazen and unafraid of people. Some have reported annual losses in the tens of thousands of dollars, saying reimbursement often amounts to just a fraction many months later — if it comes at all.
Federal officials have acknowledged that coexistence is one of the biggest challenges for the wolf program and that finding ways to solve the conflicts is the top priority for 2020.
The rarest subspecies of gray wolf in North America, the Mexican wolf was all but eliminated by the 1970s, prompting the federal government to develop a captive breeding program.
There are more Mexican wolves in the wild now than at any time since reintroduction began. The results of the latest survey show there are at least 163 wolves in the wild in New Mexico and Arizona, a nearly 25% jump from the previous year.
Environmentalists say federal employees have shot and killed 20 wolves since 1998 and an additional 22 have died inadvertently as a result of capture operations.
